SDER.org
Education Reform Report
Stony Brook researcher: 'Hobbit' fossil a type of human

July 10, 2013
By DELTHIA RICKS  delthia.ricks@newsday.com


Since its announcement in 2004, Homo floresiensis has emerged as one of the most
fascinating and perplexing twists to the story of human evolution in recent history.

The fossil remains of a diminutive humanlike creature -- a real-life hobbit, of sorts -- has
stoked wonder and scientific debate for a decade, and now a Stony Brook University
anthropologist says she has proof it's a distinct species in the family of humankind.

Some evolutionary biologists say the 3-foot, 2-inch-tall cave-dwellers who inhabited the
Indonesian island of Flores were simply small modern humans afflicted with a major medical
condition.

But new Stony Brook research of the 18,000-year-old skull, led by Karen Baab and a team
of scientists, put the prehistoric hobbit to a battery of modern tests.

They conclude, in a paper published Thursday in the journal PLoS ONE, that the creatures
with tiny heads and oversized feet represent a new, distant cousin in the tree of life.

"It is not a modern human with a disease. It is a separate species," Baab said, referring to
Homo floresiensis as a new species within the Homo genus and an early human ancestor.
Others in the family tree include Homo habilus and Homo erectus.

The skull, unearthed in 2003, is known as LB-1 and is the only intact skull of that species
that has been found.

Baab said the hobbits carry that name because their appearance and size come close to
the fictional creatures of J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Hobbit" and "Lord of the Rings."

For years, some scientists have contended the hobbits were afflicted with microcephaly, a
neurodevelopmental condition marked by a small skull and minuscule brain.

Others have argued that with a head so small and height so compromised, surely the
hobbits had Laron syndrome, a genetic condition typified by dwarfism.

A third condition put forward by some was cretinism caused by severe hypothyroidism,
which would have meant lowered intelligence and stunted growth, Baab said.

But she and her collaborators studied specific regions of the skull, called landmarks, and
found that the hobbit showed no close link to modern humans, and had no signs of the
hypothesized disorders.

The scientists also compared the skull to other early humanlike ancestors and confirmed
that Homo floresiensis was not at all like them.

Whether Baab's extensive research, which spans years and involved CT scans and other
high-tech diagnostics, can extinguish the fiery debate is yet to be seen.

Robert B. Eckhardt, an evolutionary biologist at Pennsylvania State University who has
conducted studies of his own on the same fossil, said Wednesday he has concluded the
hobbits are merely modern humans -- just short and a bit odd in appearance.

Eckhardt said he will vigorously contend, in a paper to be published later this year, that only
LB-1 -- not all members of the hobbit clan -- was stricken with a medical condition. He said
his studies with a colleague, Maciej Henneberg in Australia, suggest that all others probably
were normal humans, though dwarfish and big-footed.

"We've put forth the hypothesis, using the skull of LB-1, that we can identify a pathology
that fits a diagnosis of Down syndrome," he said.
Education and the Culture
Wars Blog
SD Education Report BLOG
BLOGS
San Diego Education
Report Home
EDUCATION REFORM
Home
Map of Site
Free Speech
Ethics in gov't
Defamation Suit
Cheryl Cox Games
Free Speech
Success
Retaliation
Coverups
Conflicts of interest
Federal Judges
College presidents
Highest paid
Gov't eavesdropping
Typical abuse by teachers
ADD at Olympics
African Am Ed
Bullies in Schools
Fixing Education
Schools and violence
Fred Kamper case
Kids bullying kids:
Jeremiah Lasater case
Bullies are popular
Covering Up
Dominican abuse
Lawyers
Stutz Artiano Shinoff &
Holtz v. Maura Larkins
Stutz' First Amended
Complaint
Elizabeth Schulman
appeal
Elizabeth Schulman and
Larkins case
Rock Star Superintendent
Failure to Think
Special Education
Anti-parent war chest
Prescilla Dugard cases
Public Entity Lawyers
San Diego Education
Report Site Map
How do upper-class
parents prepare their
kids for success in the
world?
Stutz, Artiano Shinoff
& Holtz